From L’Heure Bleue to Vent Vert and Habit Rouge to Bulgari Black – the latter
being the colour of preference: at 40 Noir/Blacks, I stopped counting – the
fragrance industry has always borrowed from the chromatic wheel to name its
products, usually through adjectives. Now trending: serving up the colours
plain. Lacoste Rouge, Vert and Bleu earlier this year, Puma Green and Yellow in
June and in between, the new Comme des Garçons Play trio, Red, Green and Black.
The operation was a quickie, says CdG Parfums artistic director
Christian Astuguevieille, with developments wrapped up in two months, the idea
being to keep the scents as simple and approachable as the Japanese brand’s “absence
of concept is creation” Play line of tee-shirts, polo shirts and sweaters.
Unlike Comme des Garçon’s Red and Green series (Incense could stand in
for Black), the new trio isn’t figurative, but what’s striking is that most of
the notes used in each scent stick to the same colour as the name, a pretty
playful idea in itself, though the perfumer Antoine Maisondieu said he hadn’t
done so deliberately.
Play Red is built around a cherry accord – and if anyone could make a
cherry edgy, it’s Comme des Garçons. The trick, Maisondieu explains, was to
veer off the classic, almondy-sweet combination (heliotropine, benzaldehyde,
adding ethyl maltol for black cherry) by using a special quality of Tolu balsam
with a cherry facet, along with cinnamon in which he also perceives a cherry
effect. Red mandarin (i.e. the oil extracted when the fruit is ripest) adds juiciness
along with fresh/caramelized contrast of aldehydes and cumin; Safraleine – yet another
tone of red – gives a leathery edge to the blend, along with slightly rosy
facets.
The result is a tart, non-gourmand cherry with burning cinnamon-candy
undertones, as good-natured and cheerful as its namesake colour: my favourite
of the trio.
Notes: Red mandarin, pink peppercorn, Safraleine, red cherry accord, geranium,
cinnamon, osmanthus, myrrh, tolu balsam.
Play Green takes off with a huge, nose-cooling gale of mint, the intensely sweet “nanah” variety
used in Moroccan mint tea, which according to Maisondieu has a slight absinth
facet. Though the mint dominates throughout, lime and juniper add fizz, basil
and lentisque a slap of sap, while vetiver roots the leafy bouquet.
Notes: Nanah mint, lime, juniper berry, basil, jasmine, mastic,
ambrette, vetiver, cedar.
Play Black is the most masculine and offbeat of the bunch, a sooty-hued scent
with a salty flavor that somehow conjures algae, another tone of black to match
the powerful Madagascar pepper oil, layering over the matte metallic diesel
tones of oxides and sticky-smoky birch tar oil. Incense picks up the pepper in
the base notes. Lavender isn’t listed, but matched with the tree moss, give
Play Black a fougère-like vibe.
Notes: Black pepper, pepperwood, red
pepper, violet, thyme, black tea, birch tar, incense, tree moss.
Comme des Garçons Play Red, Black
and Green are available in an “accordion-box” three-scent set as well as
separately, adorned with the impossibly kawaii
heart logo designed by Filip Pagowski.
I’ll be drawing a set of 2ml decants of Play Red, Green and Black. Just
drop a comment saying which fragrance you know/own is, to your nose, the
reddest, greenest and/or blackest.
Greenest: Eau de Lierre by Diptyque
RépondreSupprimerBlackest: Encre Noire by Lalique
Reddest: Ambre by Baldessarini (because it is too heavy on spice to my nose)
Reddest was the toughest one to find as I usually dismiss red fragrances since they tend to be fruity-girly in my mind. The CdG though sounds pretty interesting. I like "twisted" fruit themes. pomegranate by Jo Malone is a good one that comes to mind.
I haven't tried any of the CdG Play series, but anything that invokes cherries would be colored red in my imagination.
RépondreSupprimerThanks for the great blog and for the draw.
Greenest: MMM Untitled
RépondreSupprimerReddest: Guerlain Metallica (I think of a deep rouge)
Blackest: Yosh Sombre Negra
I find I often wind up choosing my scent based on what color clothing I'm wearing. Red for me is often Harissa or Rose Ikebana. Green? ::thinks:: Huh. I have almost no green stuff in my perfume wardrobe, now that I think of it. They just aren't notes I go for - probably my greenest fragrance is Carnal Flower, which is not all that green... Black? Well, I have Bulgari Black, but for me, I notice I often go for Tolu or No. 5 when I'm wearing black. I don't think it's about the color so much as the association with black and classic and elegant.
RépondreSupprimerI'm a huge fan of the CdG line - these sound like a bunch of fun.
This trio sounds so sniffworthy :).
RépondreSupprimerIn my own perfume cupboard:
Reddest: CdG Harissa with it's zesty blood orange and chili
Greenest: Guerlain Vetiver Eau Glacée
Blackest: I don't wear black, so usually my fragrance associations are not black either. But H&G Askew and SL Chêne are dark brownish-grey, like tree bark.
The CDG play green sounds fantastic.
RépondreSupprimerThe greenest fragrant product I own is Guerlain's Herba Fresca shower gel;
The blackest fragrance I've smelled is Rien.
The reddest: the smell of (spicy) cinnamom chewing gums.
My greenest is Fleur de Liane;
RépondreSupprimerMy blackest is not mine, actually, but my girlfriend's French Lover;
My reddest... maybe Eau Lente, with all that cinnamon.
I'd love to try the new CDG!
My choices on this steamy Memorial day would be:
RépondreSupprimerGreen: Annick Goutal Ninfeo MIo
Red: Bond N9 Chinatown (well, a red nuance, certainly not classical red... or am I influenced by the bottle??)
Black: Donna Karan Black Cashmere
Hello, Denyse!You made me curious about these CdG fragrances.
RépondreSupprimer1. My greenest is carillon pour an ange by andy tauer
2.My reddest is Rossy de palma by EloD
3.My blackest would be rien by ELoD
I love the bottles!! The coffret is really cute. They look like bouncy little aliens.
RépondreSupprimerFor red, SL's Rousse, of course. For green, DSH's Viridian is a good candidate, or the latest Aedes de Venustas. For black, that would have to be Lalique's Encre Noire.
Thanks for the review!
-Marla
Kostas, I agree red is a tricky colour to translate into scent. I'd go for a deep rose or maybe saffron -- Safran Troublant?
RépondreSupprimerCheesegan, what I love about Play Red is that it's such an unusual take on cherry, it would reconcile me with red fruit in perfumery!
RépondreSupprimerWomo531, don't know the Yosh, but you've reminded me I have a full bottle of Metalys tucked away...
RépondreSupprimerStyleSpy, when I wore colours I did that too -- now I'm an all-black lady, so I guess it can go with every scent I wear!
RépondreSupprimerMaria Ho, I love that bark-grey image for Askew and SL Chêne... Really must dig out my decant of Harissa too.
RépondreSupprimerZazie, I definitely associate cinnamon candy with red too -- if it's a smell you like I suspect you'd enjoy Play Red.
RépondreSupprimerMissK: steamy here in Paris too! And I could totally see why you'd get red (more like a brownish-red spice tone) from Chinatown.
RépondreSupprimerAna, that's two votes for Rien being black, which kind of makes sense for a perfume called Nothing. I always got lots of charred notes from it.
RépondreSupprimerMarla, you're right, they do look like cute (but mischievous) little aliens.
RépondreSupprimerIodine, I never saw French Lover as black, I'll have to revisit it in that perspective...
RépondreSupprimer1. Reddest: Une Rose Vermeille
RépondreSupprimer2. Greenest: Carillon pour un Ange or Jo Loves Green Orange and Coriander
3. Blackest: By Kilian Cruel Intentions
:)
Reddest: Multiple Rouge by Humiecki & Graef.
RépondreSupprimerBlackest: Or Black by Pascal Morabito.
Greenest: Futur by Robert Piguet.
Susan, deep roses definitely conjure velvety red, don't they?
RépondreSupprimerChris, glad to see Humiecki & Graef get another mention, it's such an original brand.
RépondreSupprimerWhat fun!
RépondreSupprimerMy reddest: Liaisons Dangereuses by Kilian
My greenest: Palais Jamais by Etro
My blackest: Patchouli 24 by Le Labo
:)
Anna-Lyssa, I am woefully ignorant of Etro and will have to check out Palais Jamais. Love the Kilian, and Patchouli 24 is up there with my favorites by the great Menardo!
RépondreSupprimerGreeniest - Diorella Dior
RépondreSupprimerReddest - Absolu Rochas
Blackest - Chergui Lutens
Reddest: Harissa CDG
RépondreSupprimerGreenest: No19
Blackest: Marc Jacobs Bang
what fun! Cybele
Green and black were the easiest to position. Eau de Guerlain is the greenest of greens and was in fact the scent I chose to wear today in Cork's surprising heat. Black is my tola bottle of Ajmal's Musk Ghazelle, which smells to me like black fur stroked the wrong way!
RépondreSupprimerLike your first poster the hardest for me to place was red. I had to sniff every bottle I own to place it, and the closest I came to it was the thick and plush Ambre Sultan. However, I settled on a very vivid scent memory of a perfume I bought my ex-wife, (the very apt).Cartier's Le Baiser du Dragon!
What a fun series by CdG! Thanks for the introduction, and for the thought provoking drawing question. . .
RépondreSupprimerReddest--POL's Luctor Et Emergo for it's cherry note? This was the hardest for me to choose. Lyric Woman was a close second.
Greenest--PG's Papyrus de Ciane
Blackest--CdG's Tar, of course :D
Be well.
--HemlockSillage
CdG Play Red sounds especially interesting. I don't think I've ever smelled anything quite like what you've described. My nominations for other colorful scents:
RépondreSupprimerReddest: L'Arte di Gucci
Greenest: Gobin-Daude Sous le Buis
Blackest: Serge Noire
CdG is such an interesting line. I have the #2 which is "inky" and I love it. Red catches my taste at first here but the black is intriguing....Green with the minty thing doesn't suit me usually...thank you for the draw opportunity.
RépondreSupprimerOkay, I'll play. :)
RépondreSupprimer(I had the hardest time coming up with the "blackest".)
Reddest: Cinabre by Maria Candida Gentile
Greenest: Atelier Cologne Trefle Pur
Blackest: SL Sarrasins
Thanks for the draw!
TaffyJ
Thanks for the draw. These look interesting. Black is, well, Black. Something about the rubber and packaging is forever ingrained on my brain.
RépondreSupprimerRed is piment Brulant for its spicy herbal ness.
Green is Chanel #19 or infusion d'iris.
Alina, thanks for pitching in. I think I've never smelled Absolu by Rochas.
RépondreSupprimerCybele, you're right, with all that pepper Bang is black!
RépondreSupprimerStephen, chuckling at Le Baiser du Dragon for an ex-wife... Perfumes are our subconscious!
RépondreSupprimerHemlockSillage, I remember when the online perfume community was all about Luctor et Emergo... They've kind of dropped off the radar, haven't they?
RépondreSupprimerKathryn, CdG Play Red manages to smell both new and comfortable, I'm really enjoying my sample.
RépondreSupprimerNancy, like you I find mint-centred scents kind of difficult to pull off. Might work in searing heat though!
RépondreSupprimerTaffyJ, I've got a sample of Cinabre, which of course means vermillion red, I'll have to explore it further.
RépondreSupprimerCM, quite agree that Black is black!
RépondreSupprimerDoes anyone remember a line that, I think, was made by Prescriptives which was an unfeadibly huge range of fragrances named after colours? It was probably about 20 years ago, and (if my poor memory serves me) there were about 30 different bottles. I seem to remember a big bank of bottles arranged in Harrods according to the chromatic spectrum (if that is the right terminology!). I think I felt that most of the fragrances smelt a bit like Calyx!
RépondreSupprimerJillie
Jillie, I missed out on that Prescriptives range completely. I think the brand was never commercialized in France, and I was already living here at the time. Curious to see if anyone chimes in.
RépondreSupprimerWill try my luck :-)
RépondreSupprimerGreenest- Eau de Campagne by Sisley
Reddest- Lipstick Rose by F. Malle
Blackest- Black Tourmaline by O. Durbano
And Denyse, do you perhaps know if original Play stays in production? Bottles of classic and Red Play are so similar, but can assume there are two different scents.
Merci! Ela
Ela, yes, the original Play is still in production as far as I know.
RépondreSupprimerThanks for the draw!
RépondreSupprimerReddest: Chypre Rouge is the reddest because the intense opening makes me think of a certain kind of red (berry) candy from my childhood.
Greenest: Papyrus de Ciane.
Blackest: AG Eau du Fier! Strong black at first but "watercolor black" when it evolves.
Mikael, I love Eau du Fier and have a large decant somewhere. It does have smoky-black tones, doesn't it?
RépondreSupprimerThanks for the draw, Denyse!
RépondreSupprimerReddest: Rousse (cinnamon-scented redhead)
Greenest: Premier Figuier (all these leaves!)
Blackest: Tea for Two (Lapsang Souchong)
Red: Micallef Red Sea (rose, cinnamon, and sandalwood). Tauer's Auburn (cinnamon and tobacco) would be a close second.
RépondreSupprimerGreen: CdG Calamus
Black: Olivier Durbano Black Tourmaline
-Janice
Green: no19
RépondreSupprimerBlack: Bandit
Red: Absolue Pour le Soir-a sort of devil-red!
Red-Coco
RépondreSupprimerGreen-#19 Poudre
Black-Black Orchid
Thanks for the draw.
Greenest: Ormonde Woman by Ormonde Jayne
RépondreSupprimerReddest: Une Rose by Frederic Malle
Blackest: Maybe...Patchouli 24 by Le Labo
Hard to see black in a fragance, but this from Le Labo is a great example, for me!
Laurinha, I'm getting lots of fig scents for "green", which of course makes loads of sense... And so seasonal!
RépondreSupprimerJanice, thanks for reminding me of Calamus. Need to get more, even a bottle. Very original note.
RépondreSupprimerEva S, Bandit is as black as a film noir, you're right!
RépondreSupprimerMaureen, since Coco was inspired by Chanel's coromandel screens, there's definitely red in the mix!
RépondreSupprimerJoaquim, you've named three scents I really love. Patchouli 24 is really pretty charred.
RépondreSupprimerI would say:
RépondreSupprimerGreenest: Ormonde Jayne Woman
Blackest: By Killian Pure Oud
Reddest: This one is harder--I guess SSS Vintage Rose or Velvet Rose
Thank you for the draw!
Hi, thank you for the draw. My first time commenting, but I'm a regular reader.
RépondreSupprimerGreen - Diptyque Philosikos
Red - Frederic Malle Carnal Flower
Black - Donna Karan Black Cashmere
I own and love them all!
Anat13, Pure Oud is a lovely velvety inky castoreum black, I agree!
RépondreSupprimerUnknown-regular-reader, great choices! If you could pick a pseudonym it would make it easier to identify you if you ever won the draw!
RépondreSupprimerI like that CDG is back to doing concept fragrances. Black and Red appeal, especially.
RépondreSupprimerSince no-one brought it up it seems kind of worth noting: the "Nanah" mint is literally just "mint" in Arabic. ( Analogous to saying "These are framboise raspberries!" )
Arabic mint tea is delicious and owes much of its charm to the use of ( frequently ) fresh leaves and a great deal of sugar, but all of the mint I encountered in the Mid-East was regular peppermint or spearmint.
I suppose Arabic ( bar "oud" ) has yet to be mined as a language for perfumery. It ought to be used more often, given Arab countries are big buyers of western perfume and the Mid-East has long been an inspiration to perfumery as a whole. Certainly I prefer "Zembeq" to "Tuberose" ( Which sounds like some rose-potato hybrid... )
Greenest: Eau de Camille. (Light green, almost yellow actually).
RépondreSupprimerReddest: I can't make up my mind. I'd say Chypre Rouge or Santal de Mysore.
Blackest: Bvlgari Black, of course.
This is a fun thing to do -associations. The only thing is most of the time, The colour in the name ends up being associated with the actual scent(!)
Sugandaraja, thanks for the linguistic input! Not sure though that a fragance reminiscent of mint tea (which already exists in the CdG Series Green) would appeal to the Arabic market: it would probably be too reminiscent of something edible and familiar.
RépondreSupprimerMathieu, true, but Dominique Ropion once told me he'd read a study that tended to indicate that certain smells were indeed associated with certain colours in blind tests.
RépondreSupprimerThanks for the draw! The greenest scent (and one of the best!) to me is Annick Goutal Eau de Camille. It's playing outdoors in the summer as a child, bottled.
RépondreSupprimerLiz, I think that was pretty much the idea since the scent was composed for Annick Goutal's young daughter... A happy vibe to get from a fragrance!
RépondreSupprimerGreen: to me, a vetiver chypre is the ultimate green, like Ma Griffe
RépondreSupprimerBlack: Nasomatto Hindu Grass, thick black hashish resin!
Red: YSL Opium :-)